Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Hugo Awards

One of the people I follow just posted a bit of news about the Hugo Awards: This year, 80% of the nominees in the fiction categories are women. The spirit of the comment seemed to be somewhat triumphalist. But I can't see that there's much occasion for triumphalism in that news.

On one hand, if we suppose this is just a random fluke, and next year 80% of the nominees could be men, then it doesn't mean anything in particular.

On the other hand, if it does mean something, what does it mean?

Are 80% of current science fiction writers female? Having men virtually abandon the field, or be unable to get published, doesn't seem to me to be cause for celebration.

Are men and women present in comparable numbers, but are women writing much better than men? If men aren't learning to write good fiction, that's a problem with their professional education and development, and one that needs to be resolved.

Are men and women writing in equal numbers and equally well, and are women getting a disproportionate share of recognition? That's an injustice, and since the Hugos are nominated by the fan community, of widespread injustice among SF fans. And if that should be the case, it would be understandable that men might be abandoning the field, if they are.

I have no idea which of these is true, but none of them strikes me as occasion for rejoicing.


Apr. 3rd, 2019 06:00 pm (UTC)
I suspect it's simply being seen as evidence that there is no longer a bias against women writers in the nominating process. That's something that it's hard to be sure about quickly, given the limited amount of data generated each year. So yes, it's a fluke that it's this high a percentage, but the fact that a fluke can go this high means something in itself.
Apr. 3rd, 2019 07:30 pm (UTC)
I think that absence of bias was already established last year when at least 67% of fiction nominees were female (I'm not sure how to categorize some of them).

Latest Month

November 2019

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel